22 September 2015

Pandan Magic Custard Cake

I must be the slowest coach to make this Magic Custard Cake; I think the whole village had already attempted different flavours of it since last year? When the craze first started, I bookmarked the recipes and added them to my long list of to-bakes but somehow never got down to trying any of them.

Anyways, recently I had a little bit of coconut milk and concentrated pandan juice left over from baking a Pandan Chiffon Cake and finally have this opportunity to attempt the Pandan flavour of the Magic Custard Cake.

As usual, I went through in detail the various recipes and variations (Baking Tai Tai, Peng's Kitchen, Aunty Young, Anncoo Journal). Most of the ingredients and proportions are about the same, except for variations in the amount of coconut milk and fresh milk, as well as the use of pandan paste vs pandan juice/extract.

Since I only have a little bit of coconut milk left, I made it up with more fresh milk. As for the pandan flavouring, I decided not to buy commercial pandan paste or essence, but to use the concentrated pandan juice that I made for the pandan chiffon cake.

Baking the cake was rather straightforward for those who have baked chiffon cakes before; first, preparation of the main batter, followed by whipping up the egg whites till stiff peak, and then folding the egg white meringue into the main batter gently till incorporated. The batter was very very watery, casting a doubt as to whether the cake would turn out successful or not. It's perfectly normal, as advised by all the bakers who have attempted the recipes :)

All was fine until the baking time was up.

I didn't have a removable baking pan, so couldn't lift the cake out of the pan to let it cool down on the rack. The cake was quite heavy and soft and I could feel it wobbling as I attempted to lift the baking parchment several times. Afraid that the parchment might tear and risking the cake smashing into pieces, I simply let the cake cool down in the baking pan, which turned out alright I guess.

After the cake cooled sufficiently at room temperature, I transferred the entire baking pan into the fridge for the cake to chill and set completely. Finally removed it from the pan in the late night, and after trimming the sides of the cake, was elated that there were three layers - the cake, the custard and the kueh. Yippee!

Pandan Magic Custard Cake
(baked using 8" x 8" square pan)

  • 115g unsalted butter
  • 115g plain flour
  • 300g fresh milk
  • 80g coconut milk
  • 100g concentrated pandan juice, room temperature
  • 4 egg yolks (I use 60g egg with shell)
  • 145g icing sugar
  • 1 tbsp pandan juice
  • 4 egg whites (I use 60g egg with shell)
  • t tbsp caster sugar
  1. Preheat oven to 165 degree celsius. Line 8" x 8" baking pan with parchment paper.
  2. Melt butter over pot of simmering water. Set aside to cool down.
  3. Sift flour into a bowl. Set aside.
  4. Heat fresh milk and coconut milk to lukewarm. Add concentrated pandan juice and stir well. Set aside.
  5. In a mixing bowl, cream egg yolks and icing sugar till light and fluffy.
  6. Add melted butter and the 1 tbsp pandan juice, mix till incorporated.
  7. Fold in flour gently till just incorporated.
  8. Fold in milk and pandan juice mixture gently till just incorporated. The batter will be watery and runny.
  9. In a separate mixing bowl, beat egg whites till foamy, add caster sugar and continue beating till stiff peak.
  10. Pour 1/3 of the meringue into the main batter, folding gently till just incorporated, followed by the next 1/3. Finally pour all the batter into the bowl of the remaining 1/3 meringue, fold till just incorporated.
  11. Pour the batter into the prepared baking pan. Bake at 165 degree celsius for 55-60 mins.
  12. After cake is done, remove from oven and let the cake cool to room temperature on a wire rack.
  13. Transfer the cake to the fridge and let it chill for a few hours before cutting and dusting with icing sugar to serve.

Personally, of the three layers, I love the cake part the best as I'm not really fond of custard or kueh. The cake was tender and fluffy, almost melt in the mouth. The kiddo tried a small piece and said it was ok, but didn't ask for second helping. As for hb, he said it tasted like pandan kaya cake, well, which I supposed was quite close in terms of taste?

Ok, so now that I've tried and tasted the Magic Custard Cake, at least it's a check-off my list. Don't think I will attempt other flavours for now.


  1. Hi,
    Can I use salted butter which I hv in the freezer? Also can I use 200g coconut milk n 180g milk?

    1. Hi,
      I'm not sure if salted butter will work here, the cake might just have a tinge of saltiness then. If you use more coconut milk, the overall cake will be more coconut taste.